Stefano Langone, 22
Just how sexy is half-Mexican American Idol alum, Stefano Langone? Well, for starters, the most beautiful woman in the world, Jennifer Lopez, spent nearly 10 weeks flirting with the tanned hottie, even though he placed seventh on Idol's 10th season. The Puerto Rican superstar even commented that he should look into her eyes and "sing to her more." With a million dollar smile like Stefano's, we can see what all the fuss was about!