Who Wore It Best? Beyoncé vs. Melody Thornton

Beyoncé accepted an award during the 2009 MTV Europe Music Awards in Berlin in November wearing Sass & Bide's black and gold minidress, gold patent leather platforms and full curls. At the American Music Awards a few weeks later, Melody Thornton wore the same dress in white and gold with black booties and a sleek ponytail. So, tell us...