Who Wore It Best? Taylor vs. Shakira

Back in July, at the opening of Sephora 5 Times Square in New York City, Gossip Girl star Taylor Momsen wore this black buffalo plaid tunic without pants. She accessorized with a stack of bracelets, a rosary necklace and black peep toe boots. Yesterday, Shakira presented her new album, La Loba, in Madrid with the same tunic faling off one shoulder. She paired it with black leggings, black nails and black lace-up peep-toe boots. So, tell us...