The Top 12 guys took the stage last night on American Idol and among them was 23-year-old Cuban contestant Jovany Barreto, who did a pretty good job of singing Edwin McCain's "I'll Be."
The judges gave Jovany mixed reviews: Randy Jackson said he basically mimicked the original song without bringing in anything unique, while Steven Tyler yelled, "Holy shipyards!" (That's a compliment coming from the wacky Tyler). And J.Lo seemed to like it too: "I'm happy right now," she said.
But what we really want to know is what you thought of Jovany's performance last night. Check out the video of his performance last night below and then take our poll to let us know your thoughts!