Happy Birthday, Freddie Prinze Jr! 37 Photos of the Former Teen Heartthrob

Say it isn’t so! Freddie Prinze, Jr., America’s teenage dream in the late 1990s and early 2000s, is turning 37 today!

The Puerto Rican actor who starred in the blockbuster films She’s All That, Boys and Girls and I Know What You Did Last Summer must have discovered the Fountain of Youth… Prinze, Sarah Michelle Gellar’s better half and a father of two, still looks like a Teen People cover boy more than 15 years after his feature film debut in To Gillian on Her 37^th Birthday in 1996! To celebrate his birthday, here’s a look at 37 photos of our very own Prinze Charming.